Great Depression Potato Puffs: A 1937 Yankee Magazine Recipe Made With Idaho® Potatoes

In 1937, with the Great Depression still gripping the country, a New England magazine printed a recipe for a party snack made almost entirely from potatoes: hot mashed potato centers wrapped in a buttery breadcrumb shell. They were called potato puff balls, and the magazine’s own modern editors later described them as an early version of baked homemade tater tots.

I made them this week with Idaho® potatoes, and I want to thank the Idaho Potato Commission for sponsoring this video. They gave me a good excuse to dig into one of my favorite topics: how a humble vegetable fed a struggling country, and how people made it feel like a celebration. They are crunchy outside, soft inside, and I rated them 8.9 out of 10.

The Potato in the Great Depression

By 1933, roughly one in four American workers was unemployed, and families who had never worried about dinner were counting every nickel. The potato was the answer to a lot of problems. It was cheap, it filled you up, and it stored for months in a cellar. In A Square Meal, a cultural history of the Depression, Jane Ziegelman and Andrew Coe describe Dust Bowl families who pared their diets down to flour, lard, and potatoes, and out-of-work West Virginia coal miners who survived on potatoes, bread, beans, and margarine. Clara Cannucciari, whose Depression cooking videos introduced a new generation to the era, said her family ate potatoes every day.

Next week

I cook these before I write them. Some of it never makes the post.

The failures, the source documents, the version that actually tasted good. That part goes out by email, and next week’s is already on the stove.

Donnie Dodson, who writes Eats HistoryWritten and cooked by Donnie

Food advice at the time was focused on stretching every dollar. Government home economists pushed cheap, “wholesome” meals, and as Coe has put it, the emphasis was less about what foods tasted like and more about how inexpensive and nutritious they were. The potato was the perfect fit.

The Source: Yankee Magazine, 1937

Yankee Magazine was founded in 1935, in the middle of the Depression, with an attitude that suited the times: make do with less. In 1937, it ran a feature called “Aroostook’s Hundred Recipes,” written by Pearl Ashby Tibbetts, the wife of a country doctor in Bethel, Maine. Aroostook County, in northern Maine, was one of the country’s great potato regions, and the feature listed exactly one hundred recipes for the crop, packed into small, crowded paragraphs. That sounds excessive, but when no crop could afford to be wasted, a long list of ways to use one was useful.

One of those recipes was the potato puff ball. Decades later, Yankee’s editors featured it in a holiday series on party appetizers from each decade, and found that the hot mashed potato centers and buttery crumb shells tasted great showered with salt and dipped in ketchup. I like how that spirit holds up. Holiday entertaining was not high on the list for most Depression-era households, but a bowl of potato puffs was a way to put something festive on the table without spending money you didn’t have.

Idaho in the Depression Decade

Here is where I want to be careful, because the recipe came from a Maine potato feature, and Idaho was not yet the giant it is today. At the time the Idaho Potato Commission formed, Idaho was not a big player in the national potato industry. But the 1930s was the decade when Idaho’s industry was establishing itself.

Irrigation had opened up new farmland in the Snake River region, and the Russet Burbank, which grew well in Idaho’s soil, gave the state a distinctive product. Potatoes were shipped east by rail, and growers like Joe Marshall, later known as the “Idaho Potato King,” pushed for quality. His Blue Diamond brand reportedly commanded a premium price in Chicago, California, Kansas City, and points east. In May 1937, the same year as the Yankee recipe, Idaho growers formed the Idaho Fruit and Vegetable Advertising Commission, which became the Idaho Potato Commission, to promote the state’s crops and gain more control over how they were sold.

Idaho potatoes also found fans in restaurants. According to the Idaho Potato Commission’s historical account, a Chicago restaurateur named Dario Toffenetti bought a shipment of unusually large Idaho potatoes and turned them into “Genuine Jumbo Mealy Idaho Baked Potatoes,” sold for 25 cents during the Depression. They became a draw at his restaurants in Chicago and later in New York’s Times Square.

One tip when you shop: “Idaho®” tells you where a potato was grown, not what variety. Look for the “Grown in Idaho®” seal. Idaho’s warm days, cool nights, mountain-fed irrigation, and rich volcanic soil create ideal growing conditions, which is why I used Idaho® Russets here. Their high starch content makes a fluffy mash that holds together when you roll it.

My Rating

The outside bakes up crunchy and golden, and when you bite through, the inside is soft, hot, and creamy mashed potato. I served mine with sour cream and chives, and the cool, tangy cream is a good contrast to the rich, buttery crust. They are simple, comforting, and easy to eat by the handful, which makes them dangerous at a party.

Rating: 8.9 / 10

Great Depression Potato Puffs

Donnie
As it was written (Pearl Ashby Tibbetts, “Aroostook’s Hundred Recipes,” Yankee Magazine, 1937):
“Pare and boil 6 medium-size Maine potatoes. Drain. Mash very smooth and light. Add 2 large tablespoons butter, 1/2 cup hot milk, 1/4 cup mild grated cheese, and salt and pepper to taste. Beat until fluffy. While hot, shape into little balls, then roll in egg and breadcrumbs. Place on a well-buttered pan and brown delicately in a hot oven. Serve immediately.”
Prep Time 25 minutes
Cook Time 40 minutes
Chill Time 1 hour

Jump To

Donnie Dodson

Don’t lose this one.

I’ll email it to you so it’s waiting when you’re ready to cook.

Ingredients
  

  • 3 medium Idaho® Russet potatoes about 1½ lb, peeled and cut into 2-inch chunks
  • 1 Tbsp butter plus more for the pan
  • ¼ cup hot whole milk
  • 3 Tbsp finely grated Parmesan the original used mild cheese, and Parmesan is sharper, so a little goes further
  • 2 Tbsp finely chopped fresh chives
  • ½ tsp salt plus more to taste
  • ¼ tsp black pepper
  • 1 large egg beaten
  • 1 cup plain dry breadcrumbs
  • To serve: sour cream or ketchup

Instructions
 

  1. Boil the potatoes. Place the potatoes in a pot, cover with cold salted water, and bring to a boil. Cook 15 to 18 minutes, until very tender.
  2. Dry them out. Drain well and return the potatoes to the hot pot over low heat for 2 to 3 minutes, shaking occasionally, to steam off moisture.
  3. Make the mash. Mash until very smooth, using a ricer or masher, and stop as soon as it is smooth. Beat in the 1 Tbsp butter, hot milk, Parmesan, chives, salt, and pepper until fluffy. Taste and adjust the seasoning.
  4. Chill the mash. Cover and refrigerate for 1 to 2 hours (or overnight), until cold and firm enough to scoop like dough.
  5. Shape. Scoop rounded tablespoons and roll into balls with cool hands. Work quickly so the mash stays cold.
  6. Bread twice. Set up two shallow bowls, one with the beaten eggs and one with the breadcrumbs. Roll each ball in egg, then crumbs, then egg and crumbs again, pressing gently to cover every spot.
  7. Freeze. Place the balls on a tray and freeze for 15 to 20 minutes, until firm.
  8. Preheat the pan. Heat the oven to 425°F with a generously buttered baking sheet inside.
  9. Bake. Place the frozen balls on the hot sheet, spaced apart, and brush lightly with the melted butter. Bake 20 to 25 minutes, turning once halfway, until deep golden brown and crisp.
  10. Serve immediately with sour cream or ketchup.

Notes

  • Cold is the secret. The 1937 recipe shapes the balls while the mash is hot, but in my kitchen the balls slumped. Chilling the mash and freezing the breaded balls keeps them from melting in the oven.
 
  • Keep the mash dry. Steam-drying the potatoes and using only 2 Tbsp of milk makes a firm mash that holds its shape.
 
  • Serve right away. The crust is crispest straight from the oven and softens as it sits.

Leave a Reply